Ogg, MPEG-LA and Submarine Patents

A few weeks ago, I published an interview with MPEG LA CEO Larry Horn on the patent group’s decision not to charge for free content encoded with H.264.

Then I got a note back from a reader who stated:

I’m disappointed. The interview seemed to be pretty powder puff. Why not ask the harder questions, e.g., was your decision in response to Wikipedia’s (and potentially Firefox’s) decision to support an open source format (Ogg Theora)? Your interview should take the real issues head on.

I checked to make sure the letter wasn’t from my high school journalism teacher (it wasn’t) and then reflected. At the time, I wasn’t hip to the whole Ogg vs. H.264 debate within the parameters of HTML 5, and simply didn’t think to ask. But then I read up on the debate, learning that Apple in particular, who is on the MPEG LA committee, has repeatedly stated that they won’t adopt Ogg because of the risk of submarine patents. See, for example, Ryan Paul’s excellent article in Ars Technica on the subject.

So I created a new set of questions and sent them to MPEG LA. This led to another round of questions, which I then sent to Xiph.org, which oversees the Theora format. I then got a very interesting response from Xiph founder Monty Montgomery.

You can read them both at StreamingMedia.com.

About Jan Ozer

Avatar photo
I help companies train new technical hires in streaming media-related positions; I also help companies optimize their codec selections and encoding stacks and evaluate new encoders and codecs. I am a contributing editor to Streaming Media Magazine, writing about codecs and encoding tools. I have written multiple authoritative books on video encoding, including Video Encoding by the Numbers: Eliminate the Guesswork from your Streaming Video (https://amzn.to/3kV6R1j) and Learn to Produce Video with FFmpeg: In Thirty Minutes or Less (https://amzn.to/3ZJih7e). I have multiple courses relating to streaming media production, all available at https://bit.ly/slc_courses. I currently work as www.netint.com as a Senior Director in Marketing.

Check Also

Take the Bitmovin Video Developer Survey

Contribute to the one of the most valuable sources of industry data by completing the …

Speech-to-text In Premiere Pro – Fast, Easy, Accurate, and Free

This video tutorial teaches you how to convert speech-to-text in Premiere Pro. I’ve been using …

Streaming Media 101: Training for App & Player Development/Testing Professionals

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *